luminosity marketing
Search search
October 24th, 2011: Edward Tufte & the Case Against Reckless Data Visualization
by Kimberly Conon

Once upon a time, in a far away land called New Haven, CT, there lived a man who would revolutionize the way analysts of all breeds communicate data. A colleague from my past introduced me to Edward Tufte (hereafter: ET, his self-proclaimed nickname) several years ago. ET is on a mission to make the world a better place, one chart at a time. Specifically: he has developed a philosophy toward design that seeks to maximize the flow of complicated sets of  information from the medium (design space) to the end user (you and me).

When I saw that ET would be teaching a workshop here in NYC, I jumped on it. I was (mistakenly) under the impression that ET was singularly a master of jamming as much information into a single chart as intelligibly possible. After all–who wouldn’t want to pick up a few good templates to add to the reporting arsenal? While we certainly learned tactical approaches to designing data outputs, ET conveyed a much richer appreciation and respect for the process of translating data into visual displays. The crux of his message is that data should drive design–and not the other way around.

The example above (Napoleon’s March – 1812, which was presented by ET) demonstrates how complex information can be amassed for maximum impact. The image overlays 1) a time series of Napoleon’s army size, 2) geographical elements conveyed via a map, and 3) change in temperature. Though it may appear overly complex, the image is pretty straightforward: it provides evidence as to why Napoleon lost so many men. As the road became more treacherous (crossing rivers) and colder, more men died. Spend a few minutes absorbing the data and I think you’ll note its elegance.

In a world where we feel compelled to visualize everything, it’s no surprise to see cartoon-like charts that are 100% style with no substance. Just because you can visualize something doesn’t mean you should, especially if you can convey your point more directly via some other solution. A pretty chart with slick graphics and lots of modules that lacks any relational depth between numbers or dimensions is NOT an insight tool–it’s just a pretty chart. And design can’t work magic where there is no meat to be found. As ET puts it:

“If your numbers are boring – get better numbers.”

(Stepping down from soap box now).

It must be said that the ET experience itself was quite remarkable. There must have been ~1,000 professionals from a host of industries–private and public sector, commercial and academic, marketing and otherwise–jammed into a huge auditorium and ready to learn from the master. We were treated to a day-long lecture that was rife with design theory, hands-on examples, multimedia, and anecdotes that actually elevated the points being made. While it would be impossible to do the day justice with a single blog post, here are the broad theories that anyone tasked with creating Visual Displays of Quantitative Information must consider:

  •  Be prepared to do “whatever it takes.”
    • The right question to ask: “How can we best understand the data?”
    • The wrong question to ask: “How can we use visualization to understand data?”
  • Zero out the interface and make it about the content. Find the most intuitive point of connection between your communication platform and those who will consume the information.
  • Always put data in context. You can achieve this by including comparisons, causality, adjacency, multivariate dimensions, and always–lots of documentation.
  • Finally (for this post): the design logic of the display must equal the intellectual logic of the analysis. In other words, do right by your information by designing a relevant presentation format–and don’t be afraid of “data density” if your analysis begs for inclusion of multiple important factors.

If you are interested in learning more about the world of ET, check out his website here.

What are your thoughts on intelligent data design?

best black friday deals
art of war quotes
south shore medical center
government shutdown military pay
c lo green

Share
Bookmark and Share

Related posts:

  1. Smart Marketing: How OK Cupid Uses Sexy Data To Sell Services
  2. Luminosity Marketing Now Utilizing Mendelsohn Affluent Survey Data Base
  3. Research in the Real World: The Puzzle of Holiday Shopping Data

7 Responses to “Edward Tufte & the Case Against Reckless Data Visualization”

  1. [...] Edward Tufte & the Case Against Reckless Data Visualization Edward Tufte has revolutionized the way that analysts communicate data. Learn more about Tufte’s beliefs and thoughts on data and visual designs…Read More> [...]

  2. Stef says:

    This is a really interesting article, especially for someone like myself who works in television news! I am always looking for inventive ways to display a lot of information and I will definitely keep these strategies in mind!

    • Kimberly Conon says:

      Stef–this must be a real challenge for you as you have limited time to display your data. I’m sure that beautiful screen over at CNBC gives you some good real estate though! I’d love to hear how you might be able to use ET’s approach in a cable setting. Thanks for reading.

  3. Judith says:

    I attended the course as well and found it fascinating – ET is quite the character and his following is impressive. I now often find myself questioning the way I present data and wanting to integrate it more with annotations and visuals, as ET advised. The course was really time well spent and I thank you for the suggestion.

    • Kimberly Conon says:

      I agree Judith–the themes presented in the course are extremely useful, especially to the extent we can change the way we think about communicating information in all settings. Thanks for reading!

  4. Maria Costanzo Palmer says:

    I’m using visual data for my current bus project. We are using a visual mapping system called ArcGIS that uses visual depictions, much like ET, to make easily digestible graphs. Here’s to interesting ways to chart data!! Cheers Kimberly.

    • Kimberly Conon says:

      Thanks for your comment Maria–you are the perfect example of how multidisciplinary these principles can be.

 
 
 
Luminosity Marketing   (646) 213.4860   info@luminositymarketing.com
HOME | PRACTICE AREAS | INDUSTRIES | RESOURCES | ABOUT | CONTACT | BLOG | PRIVACY POLICY © Luminosity Marketing. 2009